Key Takeaways
- The Crimson Desert Contradiction quest is entirely dialogue-based, so paying attention during conversations is more important than combat skills.
- Choosing the correct Weight of Knowledge answers is the only way to progress, since the game doesn’t allow you to review past clues.
- If you fail even one question, you’ll have to retry the sequence, which makes memorizing or following a guide extremely helpful.
The Crimson Desert Contradiction quest is one of those missions that looks simple but quickly turns frustrating if you miss even a single line of dialogue. Unlike other investigations, this one doesn’t rely on collecting items or revisiting clues.
Instead, it’s all about memory. You’ll need to recall exactly what each suspect said and then answer a series of tricky questions. If you get stuck, this guide covers all the Weight of Knowledge answers and the full walkthrough to complete it smoothly.
How to Complete the Crimson Desert Contradiction Quest
Image via YouTube/Dan Allen Gaming.
The Crimson Desert Contradiction quest takes place at the Scholastone Institute and is part of the Weight of Knowledge questline. To begin, you’ll speak with the Institute Steward, who asks you to investigate a stolen forbidden book.
From here, your job is to talk to multiple NPCs around the institute. Most of them are easy to find, but one suspect is hidden behind a small passage, which is where many players get confused. Make sure you explore properly and speak to everyone, because missing even one testimony can lead to wrong answers later.
Once you’ve gathered all the information, return to the Steward. This is where the real challenge begins. He will ask you five questions, each with two similar-looking answers. There’s no way to check previous dialogue, and the game won’t tell you which answer is wrong until you finish all five.
That’s why the Crimson Desert Contradiction quest feels tricky. It’s less about solving clues and more about remembering exact statements.
If you answer incorrectly, you’ll have to go through the process again. But if you get them all right, the game will move forward and reveal the real culprit.
All Weight of Knowledge Answers in Crimson Desert Contradiction
Image via YouTube/Dan Allen Gaming.
To complete the Crimson Desert Contradiction quest, you need to select the correct responses during the Steward’s questioning. Here are all the Weight of Knowledge answers in order:
- Heard there was a meeting with a noble from out of town that day.
- They were at the lab with Tarho all day, and reckon the guard’s the one acting suspicious.
- While working on their research with Grunil, they stopped by the library and got scolded by the librarian.
- It seems the library has records of everyone’s visits, except Raphael’s.
- They insist they couldn’t have stolen it since they didn’t know about the forbidden books or the ancient language.
These answers are very similar to the wrong options, which is why many players slip up. Pay close attention, especially to the third and fourth questions, as those tend to confuse most players.
Once you select all five correctly, the Steward will narrow down the suspect based on hidden knowledge that only the culprit could have known.
Bringing in the Culprit and Completing the Quest
Image via YouTube/Dan Allen Gaming.
After answering everything correctly, the Crimson Desert Contradiction quest will point you toward the real suspect, Javier.
Head toward the Scholastone Archive area, where you’ll find him behind the building. Approaching him triggers a short cutscene where you take him down. After that, you’ll need to tie him up and carry him to the designated location.
Delivering Javier to the authorities completes both the Crimson Desert Contradiction quest and the Weight of Knowledge questline. You’ll receive your rewards, including contribution points and other quest bonuses.
The entire mission takes around 10 minutes if you know the answers, but without them, it can take much longer due to repeated attempts.
Editor Recommendation’s:
- Crimson Desert Arboria Castle Strongbox Puzzle: Complete Guide
- Crimson Desert Bared Fang Quest Guide: How to Eavesdrop and Contact with the Secret Organization
- How to Defeat Antumbra’s Sword in Crimson Desert: Sanctum of Absolution Puzzle Solution
- Crimson Desert Ice Cradle Abyss Guide: How to Solve the Puzzle
- How to Enter Lioncrest Manor in Crimson Desert (Strongbox Puzzle Guide)
- How to unlock Fated Shadow Sword in Crimson Desert
- How to Complete the Duskwood Hill Ruins Puzzle in Crimson Desert
FAQs
Why is the Crimson Desert Contradiction quest so difficult?
It’s tricky because the game tests your memory instead of giving clear clues. The answers are very similar, which makes it easy to choose the wrong one.
Can you retry the Weight of Knowledge answers if you fail?
Yes, but you’ll need to go through the questioning again. The game doesn’t show which specific answer was wrong.
Who is the culprit in the Crimson Desert Contradiction quest?
The real culprit is Javier, and you’ll need to capture and deliver him after answering all questions correctly.
